Third day of testimony begins in trial for former VUMC nurse

Sadye Matula

NASHVILLE, Tenn. (WTVF) — Courtroom is in recess for lunch right until 1 p.m. Just after two days of testimony from the state’s witnesses, the trial carries on Thursday for RaDonda Vaught, a former Vanderbilt University Clinical Centre nurse. Vaught is going through felony rates subsequent the 2017 demise of […]

NASHVILLE, Tenn. (WTVF) — Courtroom is in recess for lunch right until 1 p.m.

Just after two days of testimony from the state’s witnesses, the trial carries on Thursday for RaDonda Vaught, a former Vanderbilt University Clinical Centre nurse. Vaught is going through felony rates subsequent the 2017 demise of a client in her treatment.

Watch the trial dwell under:

Breaking Information Update

Two decades soon after the patient’s dying, Vaught was indicted by a Davidson County Grand Jury on prices of impaired adult abuse and reckless murder. If convicted, she could deal with up to 10 several years in prison.

She is accused of killing Charlene Murphey, who received the erroneous medication and grew to become unable to breathe in 2017. Murphy entered the medical center since of a brain bleed. In the next months soon after Murphey’s death, Vaught was fired from the healthcare facility.

The Tennessee Board of Nursing unanimously voted to revoke her nursing license final summer months.

For up-to-date facts on what is actually taking area in demo on Thursday, abide by reporter Chris Davis on Twitter.


The very first witness identified as on Thursday by the point out was Donna Jones, a legal nursing consultant with 47 several years of practical experience as a nurse. Jones is the prosecution’s 16th witness.

Jones shared with the jury a report she ready on this situation. She stated all the techniques she feels that Vaught failed to meet the conventional of care for Murphey.

“Nursing 101 will tell you not to be distracted when you happen to be administering medicine,” Jones said.

She testified that if Vaught did not know the generic title for Versed, she should really have looked it up.

Jones mentioned if a individual scanner just isn’t available, you should not administer the treatment. Earlier testimony uncovered a scanner wasn’t accessible on Vaught’s clinic floor.

“If it’s crucial that the medication has to be supplied, double-examine the treatment with a next health treatment provider,” Jones explained. Inspite of the fact Vaught was informed she did not have to keep an eye on Murphey, Jones reported simply because Versed is a hefty sedative, it however ought to have been carried out.

Jones then confirmed the jury how reconstructing a drug is effective. By means of the demonstration, the prosecution was making an attempt to show how Vaught may have witnessed the leading of the vial that warned it was a paralytic. For a minute in the course of the demonstration, Jones briefly misplaced the cap of the vial.

After this, the witness was handed to the protection.

Defense Attorney Peter Strianse led a tense line of questioning about how Vaught was told that Murphey did not need to be monitored. Jones created the argument that the order not to keep an eye on should really have been disregarded as shortly as Versed was recommended.

Strianse then examine a trade journal aloud that argues organizations really should accept duty for medical failures. Jones stated she emphatically disagrees with the short article.

Jones and Strainse then obtained into a disagreement about the idea that a particular person isn’t going to have to have intent to be held criminally negligible.

“I know she did not intend to do it. I know that,” Jones stated.

Strainse then stated that Vaught totally disclosed the error she manufactured and participated in the investigation. Even so, Jones explained she would not concur, just before she shown almost everything Vaught admitted all through the interviews.

Immediately after a shorter mid-morning split, the condition rested its case. The jury was then excused for a moment as the defense filed a number of motions, including a get in touch with for an acquittal. The court then went into yet another recess even though Choose Jennifer Smith viewed as the motions. In the end, she denied the defense’s movement for an acquittal.


The 2nd day of testimony comprised of the health-related examiner, TBI agents, VUMC director of possibility administration and the VUMC treatment protection director.

So considerably, the scenario has developed all-around Vaught’s usage of vecuronium and overriding the drug dispensing device in an work to retrieve Versed, the suitable medication.

Terry Bosen, a pharmacist with VUMC who is the treatment security program director, reported all through the time of the occasion that labeling on the pockets for paralyzing brokers gave an further layer of warning to nurses when they clear away it from the drug case.

“There is certainly a pop-up message and an additional layer or warning that you happen to be accessing a paralyzing agent,” Bosen reported.

Bosen held up to the jury what a vile of vecuronium appears to be like like in sizing and packaging compared to a single of Versed.

The health-related examiner Feng Li relayed to the jury his workplace dominated the loss of life as an incident due to the fact there wasn’t felony intent.

Next Post

Why Tammy Slaton May Not Need Her Trach Anymore

Tammy Slaton ended 1000-lb Sisters time 3 unable to breathe. Tammy’s latest TikToks indicate that she could not need her trach for a lot for a longer time. Tammy Slaton has been recovering from a around-demise encounter just after the spectacular conclude of 1000-lb Sisters season 3, but based on the reality star’s […]
Why Tammy Slaton May Not Need Her Trach Anymore